BREAKING NEWS: Live from Old Trafford—Should Manchester United Re-Sign Paul Pogba?

BREAKING NEWS: Live from Old Trafford—Should Manchester United Re-Sign Paul Pogba?

As the debate over Manchester United’s squad quality intensifies, a controversial yet intriguing idea has emerged—bringing Paul Pogba back to Old Trafford. With the team lacking consistent match-winners beyond Bruno Fernandes and Amad Diallo, the argument for Pogba’s return, even on a short-term deal, is gaining traction. While many fans and pundits have reservations about the move, the harsh reality is that United still haven’t truly replaced the level of quality Pogba once brought to the midfield.

The criticism against signing Pogba again is understandable. His second stint at United was filled with inconsistency, injuries, and controversy, with many fans feeling frustrated by his performances. At times, he seemed unmotivated, and his exit in 2022 left a sour taste, as it appeared that both he and the club were relieved to part ways. However, what often gets overlooked in these discussions is just how much United’s squad has regressed since his departure. While Pogba’s time at Juventus has been plagued with injuries and setbacks, there is no denying that when he is fit and in form, he remains an elite midfielder with the kind of talent United desperately lacks.

Right now, Manchester United are struggling with a lack of creativity and technical quality in midfield. Kobbie Mainoo has been a revelation, but he is still young and learning the game. Casemiro’s form has declined, Christian Eriksen is past his prime, and Scott McTominay, while effective in moments, is not a natural playmaker. United have needed a game-changing midfielder for some time now, and Pogba, despite his flaws, is still capable of delivering world-class performances on his day. The question is whether he would be willing to return under different circumstances—on a short-term deal, with reduced wages, and as a rotational option rather than a guaranteed starter.

If Pogba were to agree to such terms, the potential benefits could outweigh the risks. When fully fit, he offers a level of vision, passing range, and technical brilliance that United’s midfield currently lacks. His ability to unlock defenses, carry the ball forward, and dictate play could provide Erik ten Hag with a valuable alternative in matches where United struggle to break down deep-lying defenses. Moreover, he has experience at the highest level, having won a World Cup with France and played in some of the biggest matches in European football.

One of the biggest concerns about Pogba’s return would be his injury record. Since leaving United, he has struggled to stay fit, and signing him would come with a significant risk. However, a short-term contract mitigates this issue, as the club would not be committing long-term finances to a player with questionable availability. If United could structure the deal in a way that ensures they are not taking on excessive financial burden, it could be a low-risk, high-reward move.

Another key factor to consider is how Pogba would fit into Ten Hag’s system. The Dutch manager demands high-intensity pressing and disciplined positioning from his midfielders, areas where Pogba has often been criticized. However, in a more controlled role, where he is not tasked with excessive defensive responsibilities, he could still thrive. If used properly, he could add depth and creativity to a squad that is crying out for more attacking quality from midfield.

Ultimately, the discussion around Pogba’s return boils down to the state of United’s current squad. The team lacks match-winners, and Pogba, even in limited capacity, has the ability to influence big games. While some fans may not want to revisit the past, the reality is that United need reinforcements, and if the deal is structured correctly, bringing Pogba back could make sense. It would be a move filled with risk, but also one with the potential for significant reward. The question now is whether United’s decision-makers are bold enough to consider it.